Retail Group Retracts Startling Claim About ‘Organized’ Shoplifting in 2021

In a surprising turn of events, the National Retail Federation has retracted a claim that had sent shockwaves throughout the industry. Previously, the organization had stated that nearly half of the $94.5 billion worth of missing merchandise in 2021 was due to organized theft. However, it has now been revealed that this estimate was grossly inaccurate. Experts now believe that organized retail crime only accounted for approximately 5 percent of the missing goods. This revelation has shed new light on the perceived wave of shoplifting in the United States, suggesting that the issue may not be as widespread as initially thought.

Introduction

In recent years, there has been much discussion and concern about organized retail crime and its impact on the retail industry. However, a recent retraction by the National Retail Federation (NRF) has shed new light on the issue. This article will delve into the background information, contradictory data, retraction, and correction, as well as provide a thorough examination of the phenomenon of organized retail crime. Additionally, readers will find information on how to verify access to the full article and be given an overview of the site and its contact information.

Background Information

Estimation of organized retail crime

The NRF’s claim that almost half of the $94.5 billion worth of missing merchandise in 2021 was due to organized retail crime sent shockwaves through the industry. This estimate fueled the belief that the United States was experiencing a nationwide wave of shoplifting. However, this claim has since been retracted.

Trade publication reveals faulty data

The retraction came after the trade publication Retail Dive brought attention to the faulty data used to arrive at the inaccurate figure. The NRF made the necessary edits to the claim last week, acknowledging the mistake.

Continued claims of large shoplifting operations

Despite the retraction, some retail chains continue to assert that they are victims of large-scale shoplifting operations. They claim that these operations have significantly impacted their profits and have led to store closures and inconveniences for customers, such as locked products.

Contradictory Data

Lower retail theft in most areas

Contrary to the assertion of a nationwide wave of shoplifting, police data shows that retail theft has actually decreased in most areas compared to a few years ago. The data reveals a 7 percent reduction in shoplifting incidents since 2019 in most major cities.

Exceptions like New York City

While there has been an overall decrease in shoplifting incidents, some exceptions, such as New York City, exist. In these areas, shoplifting incidents have not seen a significant decline like in other major cities.

Shoplifting incidents fallen since 2019

Overall, the data demonstrates that the impression of rampant criminality in the retail industry is not supported by the facts. Shoplifting incidents have actually fallen since 2019, indicating that the issue may not be as severe as previously believed.

Retraction and Correction

National Retail Federation retracts claim

In light of the discovery of faulty data, the NRF retracted its claim that nearly half of the missing merchandise in 2021 was due to organized retail crime. This retraction acknowledges the inaccuracies in the initial report.

Edited report to correct inaccurate figure

Following the retraction, the NRF edited the report to correct the inaccurate figure. By acknowledging the mistake and taking corrective action, the NRF aims to provide accurate information to the industry and the public.

Impression of rampant criminality proven false

The retraction and correction of the NRF’s claim highlight the importance of reliable data in forming an accurate understanding of organized retail crime. This development suggests that the impression of rampant criminality in the retail industry may have been false, and a more nuanced perspective is necessary.

Organized Retail Crime

Definition and explanation

Organized retail crime refers to the coordinated efforts of multiple individuals to steal products from various stores and later sell them on the black market. This type of criminal activity often involves a network of individuals who specialize in different aspects of the operation, such as theft, transportation, and resale.

Estimation of merchandise disappearance from 2016 to 2020

Trevor Wagener, the chief economist at the Computer & Communications Industry Association, conducted research on retail data and estimated that organized retail crime was responsible for approximately 5 percent of the store merchandise that disappeared from 2016 to 2020. This estimation suggests that while organized retail crime does exist, its impact may be smaller than previously claimed.

Real phenomenon but smaller impact than claimed

The research conducted by Wagener indicates that organized retail crime is indeed a real phenomenon. However, the scale and impact of this activity may not be as significant as initially believed. It is crucial to have accurate data and analysis to better understand the true nature of organized retail crime.

Verification of Access

Patience and access verification for readers

We thank readers for their patience while we verify their access to the full article. Verifying access ensures that we can provide the complete content to those who have appropriate permissions.

Instructions to exit Reader mode or log in

If readers are currently in Reader mode, we kindly ask them to exit that mode and log into their existing New York Times accounts. Doing so will grant them access to the full article content.

Subscription options for full access

Readers who do not have a New York Times subscription can choose to subscribe to gain full access to all articles and content on our site. By subscribing, readers can enrich their understanding of various topics and stay informed on current affairs.

Conclusion

The retraction by the National Retail Federation and the subsequent correction highlight the importance of accurate data in understanding organized retail crime. While the initial claim of widespread theft was alarming, contradictory data and analysis demonstrate a different reality. While organized retail crime exists, its impact may not be as severe as previously believed. A nuanced perspective is essential to form a full understanding of this phenomenon.

Advertisement (Optional – Excluded)

Comments

Comments section is closed

The comments section for this article is closed. However, if readers would like to engage further or express their opinions, they are encouraged to submit a letter to the editor for potential publication.

Submission of letters to the editor

Readers who wish to submit a letter to the editor can do so by sending an email to letters@nytimes.com. Letters may be considered for publication and contribute to ongoing discussions on various topics.

Contact information for letters

For those interested in submitting letters to the editor, please send them to letters@nytimes.com. The New York Times values reader input and appreciates the diverse perspectives and insights shared through these submissions.

Site Index and Information

Overview and navigation of site

The New York Times offers an extensive site index that allows readers to easily navigate through various sections and topics. The site index provides a comprehensive overview and helps readers locate specific articles or information of interest.

Contact information for the New York Times

For readers seeking to contact the New York Times directly, various contact information options are available. Readers can find the necessary contact details on the site to reach out to relevant departments or individuals within the organization.

Accessibility and work opportunities

The New York Times strives to ensure accessibility for all readers. If readers require assistance or have specific accessibility needs, they can explore the accessibility options provided by the New York Times. Additionally, the organization offers work opportunities for individuals interested in joining the team and making a meaningful contribution.

In conclusion, the retraction by the National Retail Federation regarding the claim of widespread organized retail crime necessitates a reconsideration of the prevailing narrative. Contradictory data reveals a different reality, indicating that retail theft has decreased in most areas. While organized retail crime exists, its impact may not be as significant as initially claimed. Accurate data and analysis are crucial for a nuanced understanding of this complex issue.

Starbucks Wants to Resume Contract Talks with Union

Scroll to Top